New every week
Weekly Flavor Drops
Three brand-new flavors each week, inspired by the season, nostalgic desserts and customer favorites. When they’re gone, they’re gone.
This week’s drop is live
New flavors, every week.
Thick, bakery-style cookies — soft and fudgy inside, crisp outside — handmade from scratch in small batches by Brooklyn. Three new flavors drop weekly.
Our Story
Small batches,
Small batches,
big flavor.
Baked By Brooklyn is a local small-batch cookie business specializing in thick, bakery-style cookies that are soft and fudgy on the inside, crisp on the outside, and packed with flavor. Every cookie is handmade from scratch, with creative flavors inspired by seasonal ingredients, nostalgic desserts and customer favorites.
What makes it special is the attention to detail — from developing new flavors to carefully decorating each order. Baked By Brooklyn is more than just cookies: it’s a growing local business built around creativity, quality, and making people’s days a little sweeter.
Meet Brooklyn
Christmas Came Early!
This week’s three flavors
Meet the Baker
Hi, I’m Brooklyn!
“What started as something I did for fun has grown into a business I’m incredibly proud of.”
Baked By Brooklyn started simply with my love for baking and the joy of making something that brings people together. What began as baking Christmas cookie boxes for family and friends, complete with handwritten notes and little ribbons, grew into a business built around the same feeling — making people feel special through something homemade. As a high school student I built Baked By Brooklyn, having no idea what I was doing at first, just knowing that I wanted to start. I’m involved in every part of the process, from developing and testing recipes to baking every batch, packaging orders, creating content, and getting to know my customers. To me, it’s about more than cookies. It’s about creativity, connection, and putting thought into the details. I want every order to feel personal and made with intention.
Building this business has taught me so much about entrepreneurship, creativity, responsibility, and community. My happiness is found spending hours in the kitchen experimenting with new flavors, whether it’s a classic or something completely new that I hope people will love.
My goal
To keep growing Baked By Brooklyn while keeping it personal — so every customer feels they’re getting something made with care, from something I created from the ground up.
What I Bake
Cookies worth waiting all week for
All 3 in one · $10
The Cookie Box
Can’t choose? The Cookie Box gets you one of every flavor in this week’s drop — the easiest way to try it all.
Handmade by Brooklyn
Small-Batch, From Scratch
Thick, bakery-style cookies — soft and fudgy inside, crisp outside — baked by hand in small batches and packed with care.
Order Online
Shop this week’s drop
$4 per cookie, or get all three flavors in the Cookie Box for $10. Small batches sell out — grab yours before they’re gone.
Missed a flavor or have an idea for the next drop? .
Easy as 1, 2, 3, 4
How to order
01
See the drop
Check this week’s three flavors — new ones are revealed every week here and on Instagram.
02
Pick your cookies
Grab single cookies for $4 each, or the Cookie Box with all 3 flavors for $10. --> If you want to order a different combination of flavors in your cookie box, write the details in the order notes. (ex: 2 s'mores and 1 chocolate chip)
03
Check out
Place your order online in a minute. Provide your Venmo usernname in the order notes, or select cash payment. I’ll reach out in 1-3 days to confirm and discuss pickup time.
04
Pick up & enjoy
Collect your cookies at the adress I will provide — then come back next week for the new drop!
FAQ
Questions, answered
Every week I release three new cookie flavors. Once a batch sells out, it’s gone — so order early and follow along on Instagram to see what’s coming next.
Add cookies or a Cookie Box to your cart right here on the site and check out. I’ll reach out to confirm your order and pickup time.
The Cookie Box includes all 3 of this week’s flavors — one of each — for $10. It’s the best way to try the whole drop.
Pickup address will be discussed after you place your order!
Every cookie is made by hand in a home kitchen. If you have any allergies, please message me before ordering so I can help.
Keep them in an airtight container at room temperature and enjoy within a few days. A few seconds in the microwave brings back that fresh-baked gooeyness.
Yes! Customer favorites inspire a lot of my drops. Send me a message or DM @bakeddbybrooklyn with your idea.
Join the list at the bottom of this page and follow @bakeddbybrooklyn on Instagram for flavor reveals and drop announcements.
want to get creative?
Need custom cookies
Need custom cookies
for your next event?
Interested in a custom order? Email me with your preferred flavors, quantity, and date needed. Pricing varies based on the order size, flavors, and customization, so I’ll provide an idea once I have the details. Include any additional questions you may have! Join the list below to be first in line to each week's drop!